Sep 16, 1909 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 R H E 1914 Phila(A) 7-10 1 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 11 2 1909 Detroit 11-6 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 1 6 13 5 14 Phila(A) AB R H BI W K 2B 3B HR Avg 09 Detroit AB R H BI W K 2B 3B HR Avg Collins, E 2B 5 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 .359 Bush SS 5 1 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 .277 Murphy RF 6 2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 .300 McIntyre LF 6 0 2 1 0 2 1 0 0 .365 Baker, F 3B 6 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 .300 Cobb RF 4 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0 .319 Schang C 5 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 .262 Crawford CF 4 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 .282 Strunk CF 4 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 0 .222 Schaefer, G 2B 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 .245 McInnis 1B 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .328 Delahanty PH-2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .182 Oldring LF 5 1 2 0 0 1 1 0 0 .361 Moriarty 3B 5 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 .203 Barry SS 4 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 .158 Rossman 1B 3 1 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 .130 Bender P 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .200 Schmidt C 5 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 .154 Pennock P 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .250 Mullin P 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .200 43 5 11 3 2 3 2 0 0 .283 Jones,D PH 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 .357 Works P 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .000 Jones,T PH 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 .370 Suggs P 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .000 Stanage PH 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .262 41 6 13 6 5 4 1 1 0 .262 14 Phila(A) IP H R ER HR W K Ct S B ERA BF EPC Stf GSc Bender 8.1 9 5 4 0 5 1 138 83 55 4.00 37 145(148) - 43 Pennock L(2-1) BS(2) 2.1 4 1 1 0 0 3 48 34 14 2.19 11 75(70) 10.2 13 6 5 0 5 4 186 117 69 3.83 48 09 Detroit IP H R ER HR W K Ct S B ERA BF EPC Stf GSc Mullin 7.0 9 5 1 0 1 2 124 88 36 0.86 33 150(155) 48 Works 2.0 1 0 0 0 1 1 32 18 14 1.13 9 75(75) Suggs W(1-1) 2.0 1 0 0 0 0 0 20 13 7 3.38 7 75(75) + 11.0 11 5 1 0 2 3 176 119 57 2.79 49 2 out when winning run scored DET: Jones,D hit for Mullin in the 7th Jones,T hit for Works in the 9th Delahanty hit for Schaefer, G in the 10th Stanage hit for Suggs in the 11th E-Murphy(1) Schang(3) Cobb(2) Mullin(1) Rossman(3) Schaefer, G(1) Schmidt(2) 2B-Oldring(4) Schang(2) McIntyre(5) 3B-Jones,D(2) SB-PHA Collins(9) off Mullin(1) and Schmidt(7) in the 2nd DET Cobb(14) off Bender(2) and Schang(5) in the 1st Moriarty(5) off Bender(3) and Schang(6) in the 4th Bush(10) off Bender(4) and Schang(7) in the 5th Bush(11) off Bender(5) and Schang(8) in the 7th Bush(12) off Pennock(1) and Schang(9) in the 11th CS-PHA Collins(7) by Mullin(2) and Schmidt(3) in the 6th DET Schaefer(1) by Bender(1) and Schang(4) in the 6th Cobb(2) by Bender(2) and Schang(5) in the 7th RBI-PHA Murphy(8) Schang(8) Strunk(11) DET Bush 3(9) Cobb(18) Jones,D(6) McIntyre(4) HBP-Schang(PHA) by Mullin(DET) SF-Bush SH-Barry Bender 2 PB-Schang LOB-PHA(11) McInnis 6(16) Murphy 4(18) Schang(19) DET(8) Cobb 2(11) Crawford 4(21) Schmidt 2(13) DP-14 Phila(A) 2 GWRBI-McIntyre Game MVP:Donie Bush Bennett Park, Time 4:02, 74ø, 10mph Out to CF Sep 16, 1909 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 R H E 1914 Phila(A) 1 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 11 2 1909 Detroit 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 1 6 13 5 1914 14 Phila(A) Ab1 Ab2 Ab3 Ab4 Ab5 1 Collins, E 2B 1>Fs7 G54/fo,B1 W,12 6>S K 2 Murphy RF S SB2/e2,23 S,3H Fs8 CS2(26)G63 P5 3 Baker, F 3B P3 S,13 4>Fd8 F8 9>G63 4 Schang C HBP,12 D,3H,13 K 7>Fd9 F8 5 Strunk CF S+e9,2H,13,B2 E4,3H,23,B1 S G63 W 6 McInnis 1B G31 G53 G63 G13 G13 7 Oldring LF 2>D 3>Fs7 5>K 8>S 10>L6 8 Barry SS B34,23 S G63 E3,12,B1 F8 9 Bender P E1,3H,B1 B54/fo,B1 G53 B24,23,12 Pennock P F9 Ab6 1 Collins, E 2B 11>L4 2 Murphy RF Fd8 3 Baker, F 3B S 4 Schang C Fd8 5 Strunk CF 6 McInnis 1B 7 Oldring LF 8 Barry SS 9 Bender P Pennock P 1909 09 Detroit Ab1 Ab2 Ab3 Ab4 Ab5 1 Bush SS 1>F7 PB,23 F8,3H/SF S B33H S,2H,13 2 McIntyre LF G43 S P3 SB2/e2,23 K K 3 Cobb RF S F8 SB2 F9 W S,3H,12 4 Crawford CF SB2 Fvd7 4>S 6>F8 CS2(26) 8>W F7 5 Schaefer, G 2B 2>G43 G13,12 W L43/dp Delahanty PH-2B 10>G63 6 Moriarty 3B L4 S,23 L6 G13 K 7 Rossman 1B L4 SB2 W CS2(26) 7>P2 9>W K 8 Schmidt C 3>S+e9,B2 G163/dp S F9 11>P2 9 Mullin P P5 5>G53 Jones,D PH T,1H Works P Jones,T PH S,12 Suggs P Stanage PH G13 Ab6 1 Bush SS S 2 McIntyre LF SB2 D,2H 3 Cobb RF 4 Crawford CF 5 Schaefer, G 2B Delahanty PH-2B 6 Moriarty 3B 7 Rossman 1B 8 Schmidt C 9 Mullin P Jones,D PH Works P Jones,T PH Suggs P Stanage PH 14 Phila(A) IN OUT Bender AB1-1 AB4-9 Pennock AB5-1 End 09 Detroit IN OUT Mullin AB1-1 AB4-6 Works AB4-7 AB5-6 Suggs AB5-7 End Sep 16, 1909 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 R H E 1914 Phila(A) 1 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 11 2 1909 Detroit 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 1 6 13 5 Inn Out B-S On PHA-DET Result 1-14 Phila(A) 1 0 0-2 - 0-0 Collins flied shallow down left field line, 1 out 1 1 1-0 - 0-0 Murphy lined a single to left center 1 1 1-2 1 0-0 Baker popped to first, 2 out 1 2 3-2 1 0-0 Schang hit by pitch, Murphy to 2nd 1 2 1-2 12 0-0 Strunk lined a single to right, outfield error, Murphy scored, Schang to 3rd, Strunk to 2nd, PHA 1 DET 0 1 2 0-2 23 1-0 McInnis grounded to first, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1-09 Detroit 1 0 1-0 - 1-0 Bush flied to left, 1 out 1 1 3-1 - 1-0 McIntyre grounded to second, 2 out 1 2 1-2 - 1-0 Cobb grounded a single between first and second 1 2 0-0 1 1-0 Cobb stole 2nd, Cobb to 2nd 1 2 1-0 2 1-0 Crawford flied to very deep left, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2-14 Phila(A) 2 0 2-1 - 1-0 Oldring lined a double to left center 2 0 0-0 2 1-0 Barry bunted out to the catcher, Oldring to 3rd, sacrifice, 1 out 2 1 0-0 3 1-0 Bender bunted to the pitcher, safe on an error, Oldring scored, sacrifice, PHA 2 DET 0 2 1 0-0 1 2-0 Collins grounded to third, forcing Bender at second, 2 out 2 2 0-0 1 2-0 Collins stole 2nd 2 2 1-0 3 2-0 Murphy lined a single to center, Collins scored, PHA 3 DET 0 2 2 0-2 1 3-0 Baker lined a single between first and second, Murphy to 3rd 2 2 1-2 13 3-0 Schang doubled to left center, Murphy scored, Baker to 3rd, PHA 4 DET 0 2 2 3-0 23 4-0 Strunk grounded to second, safe on an error, Baker scored, Schang to 3rd, PHA 5 DET 0 2 2 1-2 13 5-0 McInnis grounded to third, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2-09 Detroit 2 0 1-2 - 5-0 Schaefer grounded to second, 1 out 2 1 2-0 - 5-0 Moriarty lined to second, 2 out 2 2 0-2 - 5-0 Rossman lined to second, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-14 Phila(A) 3 0 0-1 - 5-0 Oldring flied to shallow left center, 1 out 3 1 1-2 - 5-0 Barry lined a single up the middle 3 1 0-0 1 5-0 Bender bunted to the catcher, forcing Barry at second, 2 out 3 2 3-1 1 5-0 Collins walked, Bender to 2nd 3 2 2-1 12 5-0 Murphy flied to shallow right center, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3-09 Detroit 3 0 0-2 - 5-0 Schmidt singled to right, outfield error, Schmidt to 2nd 3 0 1-2 2 5-0 Mullin popped to third, 1 out 3 1 0-0 2 5-0 Passed ball, Schmidt to 3rd 3 1 1-0 3 5-0 Bush flied to right center, Schmidt scored, 2 out, PHA 5 DET 1 3 2 0-1 - 5-1 McIntyre lined a single to right 3 2 1-1 1 5-1 Cobb flied to left center, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-14 Phila(A) 4 0 1-0 - 5-1 Baker flied to deep right center, 1 out 4 1 1-2 - 5-1 Schang struck out, 2 out 4 2 2-1 - 5-1 Strunk lined a single to center 4 2 0-2 1 5-1 McInnis grounded to short, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4-09 Detroit 4 0 2-2 - 5-1 Crawford grounded a single between first and second 4 0 2-1 1 5-1 Schaefer grounded to the pitcher, Crawford to 2nd, 1 out 4 1 1-2 2 5-1 Moriarty grounded a single up the middle, Crawford to 3rd 4 1 0-0 13 5-1 Moriarty stole 2nd 4 1 1-0 23 5-1 Rossman walked 4 1 3-1 123 5-1 Schmidt grounded to the pitcher, second to first double play, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-14 Phila(A) 5 0 0-2 - 5-1 Oldring struck out, 1 out 5 1 1-2 - 5-1 Barry grounded to short, 2 out 5 2 2-2 - 5-1 Bender grounded to third, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5-09 Detroit 5 0 2-1 - 5-1 Mullin grounded to third, 1 out 5 1 1-2 - 5-1 Bush singled to right center 5 1 3-1 1 5-1 McIntyre popped to first, 2 out 5 2 0-0 1 5-1 Bush stole 2nd 5 2 0-1 2 5-1 Cobb flied to right, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-14 Phila(A) 6 0 2-2 - 5-1 Collins lined a single to right center 6 0 0-0 1 5-1 Collins caught stealing 2nd, 1 out 6 1 1-0 - 5-1 Murphy grounded to short, 2 out 6 2 1-2 - 5-1 Baker flied to center, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6-09 Detroit 6 0 2-0 - 5-1 Crawford flied to left center, 1 out 6 1 3-0 - 5-1 Schaefer walked 6 1 1-1 1 5-1 Moriarty lined to short, 2 out 6 2 0-0 1 5-1 Schaefer caught stealing 2nd, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-14 Phila(A) 7 0 0-1 - 5-1 Schang flied deep down the right field line, 1 out 7 1 3-2 - 5-1 Strunk grounded to short, 2 out 7 2 0-0 - 5-1 McInnis grounded to the pitcher, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7-09 Detroit 7 0 3-2 - 5-1 Rossman popped to the catcher, 1 out 7 1 3-0 - 5-1 Schmidt singled on the infield 7 1 1-2 1 5-1 Jones lined a triple down the first base line, Schmidt scored, PHA 5 DET 2 7 1 0-1 3 5-2 Bush bunted to the pitcher, Jones scored, PHA 5 DET 3 7 1 0-0 1 5-3 Bush stole 2nd 7 1 0-1 3 5-3 McIntyre struck out, 2 out 7 2 3-2 3 5-3 Cobb walked 7 2 0-0 13 5-3 Cobb caught stealing 2nd, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-14 Phila(A) >Works pitching 8 0 0-1 - 5-3 Oldring grounded a single between third and short 8 0 2-2 1 5-3 Barry grounded to first, safe on an error, Oldring to 2nd 8 0 0-1 12 5-3 Bender bunted out to the catcher, Oldring to 3rd, Barry to 2nd, sacrifice, 1 out 8 1 2-2 23 5-3 Collins struck out, 2 out 8 2 2-0 23 5-3 Murphy popped to third, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8-09 Detroit 8 0 3-1 - 5-3 Crawford walked 8 0 0-1 1 5-3 Schaefer lined to second, Crawford caught off 1st, 2 out 8 2 0-0 - 5-3 Moriarty grounded to the pitcher, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-14 Phila(A) 9 0 2-0 - 5-3 Baker grounded to short, 1 out 9 1 2-0 - 5-3 Schang flied to center, 2 out 9 2 3-1 - 5-3 Strunk walked 9 2 0-1 1 5-3 McInnis grounded to the pitcher, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9-09 Detroit 9 0 3-1 - 5-3 Rossman walked 9 0 1-0 1 5-3 Schmidt flied down the right field line, 1 out 9 1 0-1 1 5-3 Jones grounded a single between third and short, Rossman to 2nd >Pennock pitching 9 1 2-2 12 5-3 Bush lined a single between first and second, Rossman scored, Jones to 3rd, PHA 5 DET 4 9 1 2-2 13 5-4 McIntyre struck out, 2 out 9 2 2-2 13 5-4 Cobb lined a single up the middle, Jones scored, Bush to 2nd, PHA 5 DET 5 9 2 2-1 12 5-5 Crawford flied down the left field line, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-14 Phila(A) >Suggs pitching 10 0 0-1 - 5-5 Oldring lined to short, 1 out 10 1 2-0 - 5-5 Barry flied to right center, 2 out 10 2 1-0 - 5-5 Pennock flied to right center, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10-09 Detroit 10 0 1-1 - 5-5 Delahanty grounded to short, 1 out 10 1 0-2 - 5-5 Moriarty struck out, 2 out 10 2 2-2 - 5-5 Rossman struck out, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11-14 Phila(A) 11 0 1-1 - 5-5 Collins lined to second, 1 out 11 1 3-2 - 5-5 Murphy flied to deep center, 2 out 11 2 0-0 - 5-5 Baker singled on the infield 11 2 0-2 1 5-5 Schang flied to deep center, 3 out ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11-09 Detroit 11 0 1-2 - 5-5 Schmidt popped to the catcher, 1 out 11 1 1-1 - 5-5 Stanage grounded to the pitcher, 2 out 11 2 0-1 - 5-5 Bush singled between third and short 11 2 0-0 1 5-5 Bush stole 2nd 11 2 1-2 2 5-5 McIntyre doubled off the wall down the first base line, Bush scored