| Name/e-mail | Team | AIM | ||
| Mike Roberts | 1963 STL | NL | bikemike | |
| Bob Kalec | 1974 CIN | NL | rmkalec | |
| George Bseiraini | 1982 LAD | NL | AlyahNichol | |
| Andy Weinrib | 1985 NYM | NL | andy85mets | |
| Joey Scigliano | 1985 SD | NL | fjscigliano69 | |
| Frank Aluzzi | 1976 PIT | NL | Piratesbillsfan | |
| Ross Gottlieb | 1960 CHI | NL | RossG1028 | |
| Jim Walden | 1963 SF | NL | jwwj58 | |
| Jesse Elicker | 2004 CUB | NL | nxcrimedog | |
| Howie Fortel | 1959 MKE | NL | devscoach | |
| Bob Kalec | 1965 BAL | AL | rmkalec | |
| Stu Geller | 2006 ANA | AL | dadstu33 | |
| Tom Davis | 2007 DET | AL | CrashTD25 | |
| Allan Silverwood | 1975 KC | AL | STLBandit82 | |
| Marvin Sik | 1988 MIN | AL | alextuesday1000 | |
| Ed Mikhli | 1993 NYY | AL | emikhli | |
| Marc Weiss | 2002 BOS | AL | devilscap | |
| Paul Blocher | 1949 CLE | AL | ace8120 | |
| Ross Gottlieb | 1960 CHI | AL | RossG1028 | |
| Greg Marcucci | 1980 OAK | AL | bannedumpire |
Available Franchises and Suggested Teams:
COMPLETED-AL:
Milwaukee (1983)
Toronto (1984, 1988, 1990)
Seattle (1996, 2002)
COMPLETED
- NL:
Brooklyn (1950, 1951, 1954, 1957)
New York Giants (1950, 1952)
Florida (2004)
Houston (1979, 2003, 2006)
Arizona (2000)